Score: 3

"Sorry, but spoonfeeding isn't tutorial"

submission: The Extreme RPG Tutorial

date: June 4, 2008

As the guy below said, this doesn't explain the code. The person, after the first few blocks of code, does not "know how to make the guy walk". He was spoonfed, which is to be avoided.

Score: 4

"Logic and skill?"

submission: Carom

date: May 31, 2008

I don't see where the skill or logistics comes in in some of the later levels. It's too much about luck.

Score: 7

"Cool"

submission: 300 Sticks

date: April 20, 2008

Was pretty cool, but the ending had this "I don't feel like doing it anymore" vibe to it that could have been avoided.

Still, nice animation.

Score: 8

"Whew"

submission: The Atlas Station

date: April 13, 2008

Nice atmosphere. The first time the guy shoots at you freaked me right the hell out ^^;

Score: 1

"Similar problem - can't load the game"

submission: Broken Wings

date: April 10, 2008

Whatever it is trying to load once at the gamejacket logo does not go through and the game can't advance.

Score: 0

"Decent compilation, wrong delivery."

submission: ==Hentai Gallery 2==

date: November 14, 2007

A bit of a mixed review:
Content: Hentai/image-porn, sure. It can be nice to the perverted populace of the internet. I mean, it can visualize the impossible aspects that you'd never find in truth, or be a safer output of a potentially dangerous or taboo kink. The images within were pretty high quality, I'd say this much.
It's still just a bunch of hentai images, though, which one can find nearly anywhere.

Interactivity: The menu could probably look a bit better. Thumbnails, maybe?

Personal note: Maybe I'm just strange, but something an 18 year old isn't supposed to be able to view, by law, he shouldn't be able to post either. Still, it's a bit more open ended, I suppose, the way NG and other sites are set.

On another note, I'm going to assume that by your ages, you are not professional artists, and further, that the images have not been drawn and painted by yourselves. And I'm going to go on even more of a stretch and assume you did not, in fact, get permission from each artist to have their work displayed on a newgrounds compilation.

Essentially, you're posting someone else's work and you're not giving any credit or sources of where the original images come from.

I can't, in good conscience, support a work of plagiarism.

Score: 8

"Can't cast spells in the skills window?"

submission: Mardek Rpg: Chapter 2

date: November 3, 2007

When I try to cast Heal or Aqualung, I get a "BUZZZ!" sound, and I'm not quite certain why.

Any particular reason? Is it fixable? Or a bug?

Score: 4

"Graphics and music don't make a game.."

submission: Anti-Pacman

date: August 18, 2007

Gameplay does, and this gameplay was hard to agree to.

As people have pointed out, the AI for ghosts you are not currently controlling are completely retarded - they just move at random and there's no command to make them sit still.

Hell, I should be able to not control a single ghost and Pac-man should stil be getting caught so rudimentary HIS AI is (find pellet, avoid ghost by going back and forth).

Score: 9

"I love the cutscene."

submission: Gamer Kids: NSFW

date: August 4, 2007

I lawled. That was awesome.

Score: 7

"A good game, but repetitive and too easy"

submission: Evil Nights

date: June 27, 2007

The game starts off impressive: Nice pre-rendered graphics, and good applying of them into a flash medium.

However, as soon as you get ice, you can 2-3 shot most demons. The challenge curve loosens very quickly.
Once you have 3 crossbow men, it loosens even quicker. When you have teleport, there's nothing they can do and they can only pop a house until you repair it.
I never got any damage after the second night. I only had to use a will potion once. I never had any use for the bat, and I cannot fathom any use for firewall. The spiders and thingies that are summoned (I saw 3 throughout all nights, all in the first few) die too quickly to 3 fireballs (or a freeze and fire).

Yes, it's good graphics, it looks nice and it plays well, but it's... the.. same.. thing.. over.. and.. over. The demons never change: they're all the flying bats and they all use the same technique, the same strategy, the same movements, the same speed, and maybe even the same attack power. They have no variations except their HP and their looks (and the odd summoning ability that no longer comes into play later on).

There's no boss fight. There's no ground units. There's not even an increase in the number of enemies that appear at any given time as the nights progress on. They all pop 3 or 4 at a time, at most.

Good potential, and it starts well, but it ultimately falls from the ease and repetition of the game.